Monday, 4 July 2005

Culture, Anarchy & Live8

We show, as a nation, laudable energy and persistence in walking according to the best light we have, but are not quite careful enough, perhaps, to see that our light be not darkness.
Matthew Arnold, Culture and Anarchy (1882)
A good deal of energy and a huge number of decibels were expended in Hyde Park and other Live 8 venues on Saturday night – and much of it was clearly laudable. Although some doubt arises regarding the almost inadvertent ease with one can become a moral hero these days: perform a couple of golden oldies in front of a cheering crowd, log on to a web site, turn up to a pop concert and clap, simply switch on the TV and all praise is heaped upon you. Doubtless there will be more vigorous morality displayed this week in the form of more or less persistent walking, as anarchists and other concerned parties march, stomp and limp their way around Edinburgh.

Of course it is right that we should be concerned about starvation. Yes, pictures of starving babies should provoke us to tears, although whether this weep-along-clap-along morality is entirely tasteful while one is slurping from a jug of Pimms and listening to Elton John’s sentimental inanities is a matter of conjecture. Of equally questionable taste but of hugely symbolic value was Madonna’s seconding of a highly bemused and embarrassed black woman – one of the successes of Live Aid - and dragging her round the stage as she performed ‘Like a Prayer’.

Is Bob Geldof a prophet crying in the wildness, or at least in Hyde Park? Well, he may lack the beard but he definitely has the hair. More seriously, he is most certainly a hero in Arnold’s sense, displaying as does the Hebraic virtues of a “paramount sense of the obligation of duty, self-control, and work” together with an “earnestness in going manfully with the best light he has.” More seriously yet, he and the other organisers are clearly good men and obviously well intentioned. The question is, of course, whether his light is not darkness, whether his call to action might not make matters much worse.

So, how are the G8 leaders to take up the ‘white man’s burden’ that Geldof so earnestly wishes to thrust upon them? More money could be sent, more debts relieved. But as we know from recent history, only a pathetically small proportion of the money will get through to those who really need it. At best most will end up in the Swiss bank accounts of kleptomaniacal African politicians or be spent on luxury Western goods; at worst, it will be used to prop up the oppressive regimes that are largely responsible for the people’s suffering in the first place. Do we really wish to strengthen the position of tyrants like Mugabe or buy his mistresses more fur coats?

Perhaps military force should be used to administer Western largess and to make sure that it gets to the right people. Perhaps Sir Bob and his weep-along-clap-along followers would like us to invade Chad, Nigeria and Zimbabwe. Anarchists for Neo-colonialism? It is almost as catchy as 'Make Poverty History'. Certainly we could do that, although whether the West has a taste for such large scale military intervention in Africa is more than a mite doubtful.

Certainly there are thing that could be done if only we can blink away the self-indulgent tears. First, we should make the provision of aid dependent upon the transparency of its disbursement. Secondly, we could attempt to impose an absolute moratorium on arms sales to African dictatorships (we might also ban the sale of luxury limos while we are at it). Above all, we could follow the US lead and agree to drop farm subsidies. The anarchists are clearly in the wrong place; they should be outside the Elysee Palace and blockading French farms.

Friday, 1 July 2005

Keeping Things Personal

"When in trouble, pick a fight with Britain: this is the time-honoured diversionary tactic for any French politician in difficulty."
- The Economist, 25th June, p.48

This strikes me as extraordinarily dangerous as entire countries are then dragged into what are essentially personal matters. Chirac’s already weak reputation is further damaged because of the French non vote and so he tries to distract attention by attacking the British rebate. We respond by going after the Common Agricultural Policy and pretty soon ordinary French farmers are appearing on Newsnight expressing their unmitigated hatred for all things British.

Far better would be for Messrs. Chirac & Blair to keep the quarrel to the purely personal sphere. After all, they clearly don’t like each other very much.

Thus, M. Chirac could respond to the French non vote by drawing attention to B’s rather silly ears and somewhat effeminate body language. While a news conference with Blair might go something like this:

Journalist:
Isn’t the CAP a thoroughly outmoded economic tool creating structural distortions throughout the EU & impeding technological development?
Blair:
Possibly, but haven’t you noticed the size of Chirac’s nose? And between you and me, the guy really stinks. Don't they sell Old Spice in Europe?

Friday, 24 June 2005

Datta, dayadhvam, damyata

Woken abruptly this morning at 6AM by a blinding flash followed by a massive explosion. After dismissing the idea that we were being attacked by Peruvian terrorists or Basque separatists, my sleep-benumbed mind worked out a slightly more probable cause & I was out of bed.

A few seconds of frantic fumbling in my office and all the computers, routers & switches were unplugged, the ADSL line ripped from the wall. Despite surge protectors sitting atop of other surge protectors & unlimited power supplies, I have a healthy fear of lightning. However, for any one in the field of IT, an electrical storm does provide a flawless excuse for a guilt-free lie in.

Just as I was getting back to sleep the phone rang. “We can’t get the internet on our workstations,” complained the client. “I can’t hear you.” I replied. “The thunder is far too loud”.

Thursday, 16 June 2005

On Incipient Senility & Canine Excrement

Dementia begins today, as on every day. I was having a discussion with my argumentative young son, Fu, while more than somewhat preoccupied with finishing off a programming project. Our conversation touched on the favourite subject of weird things we’d be prepared to eat. Strange things I have already ingested include snake, alligator (think slightly greasy pork), horse, durian (utterly wonderful despite the stench of rotting flesh), frog, shark & caterpillar (the mescal worm is rather tasty if the tequila is strong enough). The main thing I definitely wouldn’t eat is dog. Fu asked why. All I was able to come up with was the exceptionally inane answer: “Dogs are stuffed full of dog poo”

Sunday, 29 May 2005

Paranoid Reasoning & Damp Denim

The following recollection was prompted by two things. First, I have just read an awful description of a would-be suicide’s thoughts on hurling himself off Golden Gate Bridge:

As he crossed the chord in flight, Baldwin recalls, “I instantly realized that everything in my life that I’d thought was unfixable was totally fixable—except for having just jumped.”
The second was a chance meeting the other night with a man suffering from an obsessive fear of contamination. God knows what my final thoughts would have been had I made my leap.

The Grim Reaper walked abroad in the world of late 80’s public service advertising accompanied by images of tombs and terrifying sepulchral voices threatening a new plague. This was doubtless entirely laudable if it changed sexual behaviour and saved lives; on the other hand, I am convinced that little thought had been given to the devastating effect the campaign might have on cowardly hypochondriacs. And indeed it had an extremely negative impact on those of us of a more than slightly hysterical disposition; those who merely need to glance at a home medical book to become convinced that we suffer from beriberi, swamp fever, fallen arches and leprosy.

In that fevered hothouse atmosphere, it was all very well adjuring us not to die of ignorance, but I was living in Bangkok and hard facts were very hard to come by. What’s more the total funk the melodramatic advertising had inspired made it extremely difficult to calmly look at any factual materials I was able to acquire. I did manage to read a bit of And the Band Played On but all I was able to absorb was that blue sarcomas were somehow involved and that one could expect night sweats. The heavy book dropped from my trembling damp hands. I too suffered from night sweats.

As a matter of fact, most of us who couldn’t afford the exorbitant price of air conditioning perspired a lot at night; sweat soaked bedding was only to be expected given the high humidity and the fact that the temperature almost never fell below 100° Fahrenheit; but it took some time and several Valium for me to persuade myself that this might just possibly be the cause. It took a while longer and a few more tranquillizers before I could rid myself of the idea that the night sweats induced by heat might be masking the truly sinister AIDS-induced night sweats. I might, of course, have reflected that as I was not an intravenous drugs user and was far from promiscuous I had little to fear. But, calm reflection was not something the tropics or the advertising encouraged.

Bangkok was, after all, ‘sin city’; and we were clearly at the very epicentre of the plague. The claims that HIV transmission was only possible through the intimate exchange of bodily fluids were obviously well-intentioned lies put about to avoid general panic. I could see through this. The thing was doubtless already airborne and I insisted on my right to panic.

Then there was my friend, David, who unfortunately was even more of a wimp than me. I told him about the blue sarcomas and the night sweats; he regaled me with petrifying stories of swollen glands and hideously furred tongues. Pretty soon we would be sticking our tongues out at each other and prodding ourselves under the armpits almost every minute of the day. The result being, of course, that our underarms were severely bruised and frighteningly some of these bruises could well have been described as ‘swollen’. Then were his daily visits to my office at the university in which he would somewhat embarrassingly strip of his shirt and point a quivering finger at a small, barely perceptible freckle: “Could that possibly be a sarcoma?” Not surprisingly, the night sweats continued.

David and I would torment each other at night with constant agonizing phone calls. “I am sweating, Mark” came a plaintive voice. “Well, it is the hot season, David. Besides, I am very worried about this horrid swelling just above my belt.” “It is called a stomach, Mark”, he would reply. Often I had to resist the urge to take a taxi across town so that he could inspect my suspiciously furred tongue.

We became a kind of secret society of two locked into a mutually reinforcing cycle of self torment. We even had our own covert signals and codes. If we met up at parties, we would look across at each other’s haunted eyes and mouth things like ‘painful swelling’ or surreptitiously gesture at the glands at the back of our ears with looks of barely restrained horror. This went on for months.

The climax came on a study trip to Lampang in Northern Thailand. After a hot and distinctly uncomfortable day surveying temples with the archaeology department, I retired to my hotel room and took off my shirt. It was then that I glanced across into the mirror and confronted my worst fears: my entire upper body was a sinister dark blue. I was doomed.

David & I had often discussed what to do in such an eventuality. There could obviously be no hesitation. With some effort I forced open the window, felt a blast of hot air against my face and looked down at the grimy alley seven storeys below. The fall should definitely do the trick and there was no one about. Nor was there any real need for a suicide note: the ghastly blue markings across my chest would offer mute testimony to why I had taken my life. I prepared to throw myself out and started to drink the contents of the drinks cabinet. If I were to hurl myself into oblivion I was dammed if I would do it sober.

The drinks cabinet nearly exhausted, I happened to notice that labels on some of the miniature bottles of gin, whiskey & vodka had taken on exactly the same hue as my chest. “Hum”, I thought, “it is obviously extremely contagious”. It had even spread to the handle of the fridge. Rather more strangely I found that the ‘sarcomas’ on my chest could be erased with vigorous rubbing. Even without the benefit of any medical knowledge and despite the effect of the drinks, this struck me as distinctly odd. It was then that my eyes were drawn to the real source of the contagion: my brand new denim Thai Farmer’s shirt which was still moist and dripping blue dye from the day’s exertions.

I still wasn’t convinced that I was all clear. The malevolently intelligent sarcoma might be using the dye as a camouflage. Such was the power of paranoid reasoning that it took several visits to the excellent Bangkok Christian Hospital to reassure me that I was not infected. And even then I couldn’t look at the Grim Reaper posters without a shiver, although there was one respect in which they were spot on: ignorance can kill.